Drive Genius Review

As any self respecting Mac geek, I’ve put together a toolbox to address the various computer problems I come across. One tool I’ve come to rely upon is Drive Genius 2 from ProSoft Engineering.

Drive Genius 2 is a jack-of-all-trades for Mac hard drive maintenance and repair. It includes modules for troubleshooting, repairing, defragmenting, partitioning, shredding, and even editing sectors. The geek meter goes all the way to 11 on this one.

The diagnosis, repair, and drive slimming tools are excellent. I own a few drives that don’t have the automatic S.M.A.R.T diagnosis built in and Drive Genius is a big help. Likewise, the drive slimming module found several large files that had completely dropped off my radar.

The repartition tool must involve some dark magic. It allows you to repartition your drive without reformating. Using Drive Genius 2, repartition does not equal reformat. Amen. If you partition your drives, this one tool alone could be reason enough to buy Drive Genius. 2

With Drive Genius you can do just about anything you want to your hard drives and a couple things you may want to avoid. For instance, I have always avoided defragmenting my Mac hard drives.

I’ve read conflicting authorities as to whether or not this is a good thing. In the interest of science, I decided to take one for the team and repartition as part of this review. The results were inconclusive. While my computer did not turn into a burning hunk of metal, performance didn’t noticeably improve either. I don’t see myself defragging often, if ever, in the future. However, I know some users that work with large media files who swear by it. Regardless, Drive Genius 2 gives you the option.

One complaint I have with this application is the user interface. The application launches into a 3d environment with several (but not all) of the application modules available to you. There are no labels over the icons so in order to figure out what any one module is, you have to click on the icon and wait for the application go through a several second animation sequence that sweeps you down to the icon. If you clicked the wrong icon, you have to sweep back up to the large view and start over again. To further complicate matters, there is an arrow that rolls your current icons out and a new set in. At no point are all the module icons on the screen at the same time. It just feels gimmicky to me which is kind of bizarre in light of the fact that the actual Drive Genius modules feel rock solid. The application also has some animations and graphics in its individual modules. I did not find those obtrusive at all. So you have exceptional utility software tied to an awkward user interface. It would have felt so much better if they just had all of the icons on one screen with a little summary of what each one does with mouse-over. Hopefully this will get fixed in a future build. Thankfully, there is a drop down menu that simply lists the module names and allows you to skip the fancy graphics.

My heartburn with the interface aside, Drive Genius 2 is a trustworthy utility to keep in your Mac toolbox. It also is useful for routine maintenance. A license runs $99 and you can get more information at ProSoftEngineering.com. I would recommend this application as a good investment for anyone serious about drive maintenance and troubleshooting.

You can listen to this review on Surfbits Macreviewcast #197


26 Comments Drive Genius Review

  1. tenex@tesco.net

    I bought this recently so I’m new to the app but I’m interested to know if you’ve run the “find duplicate files” option? If so how did you find it and how long did it take?

    I’d really like it to generate a report before taking action but the brief info suggests you have to allow it to run without reference to reporting.

    Any thoughts?

    Reply
  2. tenex@tesco.net

    I bought this recently so I’m new to the app but I’m interested to know if you’ve run the “find duplicate files” option? If so how did you find it and how long did it take?

    I’d really like it to generate a report before taking action but the brief info suggests you have to allow it to run without reference to reporting.

    Any thoughts?

    Reply
  3. tenex@tesco.net

    I bought this recently so I’m new to the app but I’m interested to know if you’ve run the “find duplicate files” option? If so how did you find it and how long did it take?

    I’d really like it to generate a report before taking action but the brief info suggests you have to allow it to run without reference to reporting.

    Any thoughts?

    Reply
  4. tenex@tesco.net

    I bought this recently so I’m new to the app but I’m interested to know if you’ve run the “find duplicate files” option? If so how did you find it and how long did it take?

    I’d really like it to generate a report before taking action but the brief info suggests you have to allow it to run without reference to reporting.

    Any thoughts?

    Reply
  5. tenex@tesco.net

    I bought this recently so I’m new to the app but I’m interested to know if you’ve run the “find duplicate files” option? If so how did you find it and how long did it take?

    I’d really like it to generate a report before taking action but the brief info suggests you have to allow it to run without reference to reporting.

    Any thoughts?

    Reply
  6. horizon@msbx.ws

    “The repartition tool must involve some dark magic. It allows you to repartition your drive without reformating. Using Drive Genius 2, repartition does not equal reformat. Amen. If you partition your drives, this one tool alone could be reason enough to buy Drive Genius. 2”

    Actually, while not exactly intuitive, Leopard’s Disk Utility will allow you to repartition any drive without erasing it. It will allow the addition and removal of partitions and resizing. However, the one thing still missing is the ability to actually move partitions.

    Reply
  7. horizon@msbx.ws

    “The repartition tool must involve some dark magic. It allows you to repartition your drive without reformating. Using Drive Genius 2, repartition does not equal reformat. Amen. If you partition your drives, this one tool alone could be reason enough to buy Drive Genius. 2”

    Actually, while not exactly intuitive, Leopard’s Disk Utility will allow you to repartition any drive without erasing it. It will allow the addition and removal of partitions and resizing. However, the one thing still missing is the ability to actually move partitions.

    Reply
  8. horizon@msbx.ws

    “The repartition tool must involve some dark magic. It allows you to repartition your drive without reformating. Using Drive Genius 2, repartition does not equal reformat. Amen. If you partition your drives, this one tool alone could be reason enough to buy Drive Genius. 2”

    Actually, while not exactly intuitive, Leopard’s Disk Utility will allow you to repartition any drive without erasing it. It will allow the addition and removal of partitions and resizing. However, the one thing still missing is the ability to actually move partitions.

    Reply
  9. horizon@msbx.ws

    “The repartition tool must involve some dark magic. It allows you to repartition your drive without reformating. Using Drive Genius 2, repartition does not equal reformat. Amen. If you partition your drives, this one tool alone could be reason enough to buy Drive Genius. 2”

    Actually, while not exactly intuitive, Leopard’s Disk Utility will allow you to repartition any drive without erasing it. It will allow the addition and removal of partitions and resizing. However, the one thing still missing is the ability to actually move partitions.

    Reply
  10. horizon@msbx.ws

    “The repartition tool must involve some dark magic. It allows you to repartition your drive without reformating. Using Drive Genius 2, repartition does not equal reformat. Amen. If you partition your drives, this one tool alone could be reason enough to buy Drive Genius. 2”

    Actually, while not exactly intuitive, Leopard’s Disk Utility will allow you to repartition any drive without erasing it. It will allow the addition and removal of partitions and resizing. However, the one thing still missing is the ability to actually move partitions.

    Reply
  11. kac_gy@yahoo.com

    Why am I allowed to download this and then the documentation states that I need to boot from the DVD (which of course you don’t have if you download) to run the utilities so that I can improve my hard drive.

    I love Macs but it just seems ridiculous that on a PC I can run system diagnostics on the drive I have the application installed on but I can’t do the same with my Mac.

    Reply
  12. kac_gy@yahoo.com

    Why am I allowed to download this and then the documentation states that I need to boot from the DVD (which of course you don’t have if you download) to run the utilities so that I can improve my hard drive.

    I love Macs but it just seems ridiculous that on a PC I can run system diagnostics on the drive I have the application installed on but I can’t do the same with my Mac.

    Reply
  13. kac_gy@yahoo.com

    Why am I allowed to download this and then the documentation states that I need to boot from the DVD (which of course you don’t have if you download) to run the utilities so that I can improve my hard drive.

    I love Macs but it just seems ridiculous that on a PC I can run system diagnostics on the drive I have the application installed on but I can’t do the same with my Mac.

    Reply
  14. kac_gy@yahoo.com

    Why am I allowed to download this and then the documentation states that I need to boot from the DVD (which of course you don’t have if you download) to run the utilities so that I can improve my hard drive.

    I love Macs but it just seems ridiculous that on a PC I can run system diagnostics on the drive I have the application installed on but I can’t do the same with my Mac.

    Reply
  15. kac_gy@yahoo.com

    Why am I allowed to download this and then the documentation states that I need to boot from the DVD (which of course you don’t have if you download) to run the utilities so that I can improve my hard drive.

    I love Macs but it just seems ridiculous that on a PC I can run system diagnostics on the drive I have the application installed on but I can’t do the same with my Mac.

    Reply
  16. slwill21949@me.com

    I’m with Kojo on this one about the PC/Mac thing. Plus, I actually bought the boxed DVD, but I haven’t been able to get my Mac to boot from the DVD yet, so it’s never worked for me. I’ve just about concluded that the DVD is bad and buy a new one, but I hate to put out another $100. Any suggestions?

    Reply
  17. slwill21949@me.com

    I’m with Kojo on this one about the PC/Mac thing. Plus, I actually bought the boxed DVD, but I haven’t been able to get my Mac to boot from the DVD yet, so it’s never worked for me. I’ve just about concluded that the DVD is bad and buy a new one, but I hate to put out another $100. Any suggestions?

    Reply
  18. slwill21949@me.com

    I’m with Kojo on this one about the PC/Mac thing. Plus, I actually bought the boxed DVD, but I haven’t been able to get my Mac to boot from the DVD yet, so it’s never worked for me. I’ve just about concluded that the DVD is bad and buy a new one, but I hate to put out another $100. Any suggestions?

    Reply
  19. slwill21949@me.com

    I’m with Kojo on this one about the PC/Mac thing. Plus, I actually bought the boxed DVD, but I haven’t been able to get my Mac to boot from the DVD yet, so it’s never worked for me. I’ve just about concluded that the DVD is bad and buy a new one, but I hate to put out another $100. Any suggestions?

    Reply
  20. slwill21949@me.com

    I’m with Kojo on this one about the PC/Mac thing. Plus, I actually bought the boxed DVD, but I haven’t been able to get my Mac to boot from the DVD yet, so it’s never worked for me. I’ve just about concluded that the DVD is bad and buy a new one, but I hate to put out another $100. Any suggestions?

    Reply
  21. David

    I wouldn't touch this software. I've read far too many reports of drives being corrupted after running the defrag tool.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *