The Siri Problem

Two things occur to me with regard to Siri and its related voice recognition:

  1. Even after several months, I still think it is magical. I use it all the time.

  2. It’s unreliable. Particularly, the service is down about 20% of the time I use it. Sometimes when I just dictate with it (not using Siri but instead speech recognition), the service just fails. No blinking purple circles. No text. Just quiet failure.

The combination of these two factors is maddening. If the service blows and is unreliable, nobody cares. But combining “useful” with “unreliable” makes me want to break things. I suspect this problem is server related and fixable. However, there is a limit to everyone’s patience and fixing it needs to be a priority.

Upgrading Instapaper with Third Party Apps

I consider Instapaper a transformative technology. It changed, for the better, what and how I read. I have a collection of RSS feeds and twitter friends that throw interesting links at me every day. From all of those sources I quickly select bits and pieces for reading later, in Instapaper. Both my twitter client (Tweet Bot) and RSS reader (Reeder) make this painless. I’ve taken the time to create folders in my Instapaper accounts so whatever I’m feeling like reading, I just need to tap a button and my own self curated magazine appears.

I love Instapaper so much that when Instapaper announced a subscription plan of $1 per month (with no initial extra features or benefits), I jumped on it. I’m dependent on Instapaper and paying $1 a month to help keep the lights on was an easy call.

This investment however is starting to pay off. There are some third party Mac apps appearing that help supercharge your Instapaper account. Two I’ve been enjoying lately are Read Now and Readomator

Read Now

I’ve wondered why Instapaper never created a native Mac OS X app. I suspect it probably has something to do with the insane number of iOS devices out there and the way Marco Arment lovingly sweats every detail. Regardless, someone else did create a Mac OS X Instapaper app, called Read Now. Read Now, $5, hooks into your Instapaper (or Read it Later account) and gives you an attractive alternative to the Web browser. (You need to have a paid Instapaper account for this to work.)

The overall spit and polish of Read Now reminds me of the refined minimalism of the Reeder RSS reader on the Mac. Read Now looks fantastic in full screen mode on my MacBook Air. While granted Instapaper has a clean enough web interface (shown below), I’d argue Read Now is visually the better experience.

Read Now has a few light and dark looks in addition to the paper view (pictured). You can also adjust the typography and font size. Read Now accommodates sharing to Bit.ly, Twitter, Pinboard, Delicious, and Evernote.

The general preferences give you the usual switches and buttons to control the interface and badge icons. One of the first things I did was turn off the badge icon. I’m weird that way.

Where the app falls down a little bit for me is keyboard controls and gestures. There are only three assignable keyboard shortcuts, all of which relate to operating Read Now (such as “Open Read Now”).

What I’d like is the ability to send articles to folders or the archive with keyboard shortcuts. This option doesn’t exist. Instead, you’ve got to click and drag. Ugg. (2011-01-05 Correction: Opt-A sends an article to the archive. There still is no way to keyboard save to folders.) Using Brett Terpstra’s Instapaper Beyond plugin on the Instapaper website, I can file articles with keyboard shortcuts. I’m hoping the developer sends some love to us keyboard jockeys with a future release. Likewise the gesture controls are a little nutty. With Lion you move between articles with 4 fingers while simultaneously holding down the Alt (Option) key.

While all of this results in slowing me down a bit, I’m sticking with Read Now. The ability to escape the browser and give Instapaper its own space on my Mac hooked me.

Readomator

Readomator, $4, automates the process of turning Instapaper articles into spoken word tracks in iTunes. In fairness, setting up an Automator script to do this for you really isn’t that hard. Nevertheless, for $4, Readomator gets the job done and takes all of the work out of the process. Again, this requires a subscription Instapaper account.

Once you punch in your Instapaper account name and password, Readomator presents your list of articles. By pressing the podcast button at the top of the screen, Readomator goes into your iTunes account and creates a podcast based on your currently selected folder. Inside that podcast you can “get” an article. Readomator then grabs the relevant article text, converts it to audio, and drops the audio podcast into your podcast feed. That is it. No more steps. The next time you sync up, the podcast loads and you can listen to your favorite Instapapered (is that a word?) article.

The Readomator preferences lets you set the reading speed and voice. Mac OS X Lion added several good new voices. Currently, Serena reads my selected articles on my morning commute.

I’m really pleased to see these apps growing out of Instapaper and hope enterprising developers continue to make Instapaper awesome.

Sponsor: The Master of Information Systems Management degree from Carnegie Mellon University

Carnegie Mellon University’s Master of Information Systems Management (MISM) degree with a Business Intelligence and Data Analytics (BIDA) concentration combines business process analysis and predictive modeling, GIS mapping, analytical reporting, segmentation analysis, and data visualization.

With this toolkit, students in the MISM-BIDA program are equipped to integrate cutting edge information and analytic technology practices with applied business methods. The program features world-renowned faculty teaching a cohesive blend of data analytics, management, strategy, and IT courses. It is this unique mix that makes Carnegie Mellon graduates highly valued by corporate recruiters from financial service firms, consulting companies, technology agencies and start-up organizations.

Learn more at Carnegie Mellon Heinz College.

Byline

I just checked my mail and found this month’s Macworld magazine with my Autosave article printed in it. I know I’m supposed to play this cool but I have to admit seeing my name there makes me giddy.

Chipotle Mexican Grill, Three Stars

See that false burrito. See it swaddled in tinfoil on the desk in the bowels of that great tower, a bundle of meat and sauce in a place long ago ceded to silicone and copper. The stooped man eating that peasant food as if in consuming it he can escape to a farmfield in a verdant valley and look down and see blood running from his blisters and say, yes this is work. This is work.

I wish I remember who first pointed me at the YelpingWithCormac Tumbler blog (I think Kottke) but man do I love every entry.

Happy Font Day

In addition to watching bowl games, today is the best day of the year to buy some new fonts at ComicBookFonts.com. Everything is $20.12. I buy a new one every year. If you like interesting typography, you should too.

Home Screens – Michael Schechter

Michael Schechter (Twitter) publishes A Better Mess, where he writes about productivity and creativity. Michael is among that breed of bloggers that keeps up a day job and still makes time to create something special for the rest of us. So Michael, show us your home screen.

What are your most interesting home screen apps?

I recently moved from Manhattan to Brooklyn and now spend an extra hour every workday on the subway. In fact, I’m writing this right on the iPhone while sitting on the B-Train. So as you can imagine, this extra time has helped me grow quite close with my home screen. Most of that time is split between three apps: Simplenote for writing, Instapaper for reading and Instacast for listening. While these may not be all that exciting, they are the most useful to me and are where I spend the bulk of my time. Between my full-time job and two young kids, my commute is oddly the best time time for learning and creating; those apps make that possible.

What is your favorite app?

Instapaper, by a large margin. Not only has it changed the way I read, but the way I educate myself. The ability to seamlessly pull articles, blog posts and email newsletters into one place for offline reading was a game changer for me. Combine that with the ability to send quotes to Tumblr and send items to Omnifocus when an article requires me to create a task and it’s easy to see why I yell at anyone with an iPhone to give Marco his $5.

Which app is your guilty pleasure?

I spend far too much time in Instacast, especially with the 5by5 and 70Decibel networks. It’s one part pure enjoyment and one part necessity. I know a lot of people require boredom to do their best thinking, but I’ve never really fared well with it. Podcasts seem to be this great middle ground where I can focus on what I’m listening to yet somehow allow my mind to wander. It’s common that I’ll be listening along and an idea will resonate or an errant thought will fly by. The iPhone makes it so easy to shift gears, jump into Simplenote and capture the idea for a future project (occasionally I’ll end up riding that momentum and write an entire post). Instagram is worth noting as a close runner up, as I tend to take an excessive number of pictures of my two little girls.

What is the app you are still missing?

I’m going to cheat a little here and talk about a feature that I wish more apps included. While I’m not a huge fan of notifications, I have the short term memory of a goldfish and the current notification system makes them all too easy to overlook. It’s the reasons I prefer Due over Reminders, even in lieu of Reminders’ Siri integration and location-based notifications. The fact that Due persists until I do the thing I need to do is invaluable for small, easily forgettable tasks, the very tasks that often save my marriage and career. I guess if I was forced to sum it up as an app, I wish there was a notification app for my notifications…

How many times a day do you use your iPhone/iPad?

I think it is safe to assume that should/when my wife leaves me, the iPhone will be stated as the cause. Checking my phone has become a bit of an addiction; it’s a habit I really need to break. It’s more than just enjoyment, it has become a big part of both my personal and professional workflows. I have the world’s worst handwriting and a generally poor relationship with paper, so the phone is always my go-to device for capturing tasks and thoughts throughout the day. It has become such a big part of my day that I just forget to put the damn thing down sometimes.

As for the iPad, it plays a lesser role (it just doesn’t fit well with a rush-hour subway crowd), but for tasks like mind mapping, the additional screen real estate is a must.

What is your favorite feature of the iPhone/iPad?

I’m a big fan of the integration between third-party apps. They’ve created a tapestry of tech that lets me accomplish a previously improbable amount when away from my desk. The marriage of TextExpander and Simplenote is a perfect example of how an app that appears to be as bare bones as Simplenote can prove to be so useful.

If you were in charge at Apple, what would you add or change?

I wish that some of that same third-party integration would make its way into Apple’s own apps (I know it will never happen, but a boy can dream, can’t he?). This is especially painful for managing email and it forces me to use the device for triage more than processing. The lack of TextExpander integration has been troubling to me, especially when it comes to handling customer service requests for our business. Then again, I now spend time on the subway reading and writing for myself rather than responding to work emails, so maybe they are onto something there…

Anything else you’d like to share?

It may seem silly, but take the time to figure out what you want from the phone. For the longest time, my phone was a dumping ground. I just kept downloading apps with no real thought as to where they should go, why I needed them and how many was enough. Over the past year, I’ve really evolved my relationship with the home screen. I decided to rethink my usage and made three simple rules: 1) no folders on the home screen, 2) no more than two pages worth of apps (including the home screen) and 3) Minimize notifications and eliminate badges with the exception of new texts, voicemails and overdue Omnifocus tasks. These may seem like an arbitrary limitation, but the lack of alerts help keep me focused and the real estate restrictions forced me to think long and hard about how I wanted to use the device.

Thanks Michael.

Click here for more home screens.

MacSparky Joins The Syndicate

I am extremely grateful to Timeline 3d for sponsoring MacSparky throughout 2011. Adam is very generous and continues to make the best damn timeline app for any platform.

In 2012 I’m going to be joining The Syndicate along with several of my favorite bloggers. This will result in a weekly post from a preferred sponsor. I don’t think this will interfere too much with the reader experience and it helps me keep the lights on.